Phil Cooke

AT YOUR NEXT EVENT
"Discover what you were
born to accomplish...."
MORE INFO >>

The Art of the Non-Story

The recent “revelation” of video footage from a pre-Katrina meeting with President Bush has stirred up controversy regarding when he knew about the severity of the storm.  But the fact is, the best thing we’ll get out of the situation is an example of the power of media to “re-manufacture” a non-story.

There has never been any question the meeting took place with President Bush and FEMA officials, including Michael Brown.  That’s always been public.  In fact, in the investigation after the story, an actual  transcript of the meeting has always been available.  So we have no new information, content, or insight.  All we have is video.

But video makes for much better news stories, so “when you’ve got it, flaunt it,” seems to be the mantra at the networks.  By contrast, even George Stephanopoulos remarked this morning on Good Morning America that the video revealed a very “engaged” President Bush, who understood the situation and was highly involved in the meeting.

Yet most media outlets are portraying the footage as if it was somehow “a new revelation” that once again shows the Bush administration to have failed the American people.

No new content, no new information.  Just new video of people sitting around desks. Clear visual evidence of the power of “perception” over “reality.”

Check out more comments at Captain’s Quarters.

This entry was posted on Thursday, March 2nd, 2006 at 11:15 am and is filed under General. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

  • edifimatt

    Having been a television & sports news producer for nearly 10 years…you’ve hit a chord with me on this one.  Part of the reason I am no longer in a local (or for that matter, National) news atmosphere is dueto the silliness you bring up in this post. 

     
    The pressure for "new" (notice it lacks the "s") supercedes the assumed mission of a newsroom.  This is a perfect example of a combination of things…(and I’ll leave the political agenda discussion for a different day).   
     
    Ridiculously short news cycle…a ton of "competition"…WAY too much programming time to fill…very small, young staffs that don’t know the term "enterprise" exists anymore…talking "down" to a supposed "uninformed, dumb" audience (hey…we play the role well)…and the list goes on.
     
    We set the media’s agenda with our remotes.  Unfortunately it takes a while to turn the Queen Mary…especially when intelligent, passionate people have left the industry in DROVES frustrated and worn by all of the above.
     
    I constantly talk to my friends in local news…encouraging them to tell positive, life-impacting stories.  I feed those stories to them, and honestly…they often devour them and want more.  They just don’t know how to go find these types of stories themselves and aren’t convinced the public really cares.  MUCH easier for an overtaxed local newsroom that is producing upwards of 6-8 hours of programming a day to chase fires, robberies, news conferences and newspaper headlines.
     
    Maddening, but true.  While I am no longer in the thick of that environment, I refuse to run and hide.  I will keep emailing, calling, feeding postive story ideas…
     
    Just wish there were more like me willing to do the same. (HELLO……CHURCH!!!!!!)
     
    Matt Gould
    Senior Producer
    Edifi Media
    Buffalo, NY 
     
  • edifimatt

    Just in case you’d like to know how easy it is to get your story on the air…and how desperate these stations are for anything "different"…check out this link from a local Buffalo news station (that has seen a big ratings hike of late)

     
     
    Why fight Hollywood when you have desperate news affiliates with air time to fill right in your own back yard?!
     
    (Being a bit sarcastic, of course)